Kesedihan Melanda

Huwaaaa... it happened for 2nd time.
Paper aku kena reject lagik.. Kali kedua dah ni.. paper yg sama.. hantar ke conference berbeza.
Takde novelty katanya..

PLEAASEE HATI... JANGAN GIVE UP YET...!!!!

Below please find review comments from the Program Committee of ADHOCNETS 2019 to your submission Congestion Analysis on Geographic Forwarding Routing Protocols With Cross-Layering Mechanism in Wireless Sensor Network:

Review #1
In this paper, the authors studied geographic forwarding routing protocols for wireless sensor networks. Simulation results were provided.
Some problems in the paper are as follows.
1. The paper lacks of novelty. There is no new protocol design or analysis. The simulation results provided are not quite interesting.

Review #2
The purpose of this paper is to investigate the impact of congestion on geographic forwarding routing protocols in WSN. Two protocols are considered, including DWSIGF and FuGeF. However, the authors only gave a brief introduction of the considered protocols, and then presented some simulation results to compare their performance. Although the paper gives some conclusions based on the simulation results, it lacks original technical contributions and the conclusions obtained are not of much value to the community.

Review #3
The paper presents a simulation study to investigate the impact of congestion on two geo-routing protocols, i.e., DWSIGF, FuGeF, and compare their performance. In general, the novelty of the paper is very limited. The technical content is trivial without indepth analysis. As a paper focusing on a simulation study, it is expected to include more comprehensive simulation results. Moreover, there are a number of writing errors in the manuscript. The presentation of the paper has much room to improve. The paper in its current form does not reach the criteria for publication at a conference.